Most articles offering a password manager comparison end with a ranking in which the vendor paying the highest affiliate commission happens to win. We are doing it differently. We compare four password managers we actually know, one of which we run on our own server: Bitwarden, KeePassXC, 1Password and Proton Pass. None of them pays us, and there is not a single affiliate link on this page.
The short answer first: for most people Bitwarden is the best choice, because its free plan already covers everything that matters. If you want no cloud at all, use KeePassXC. If you are happy to pay for the smoothest experience, use 1Password. And if you already live in Proton’s world or want lots of email aliases, Proton Pass is a strong pick.
The details are more interesting than the ranking. On 17 November 2026 we read the current pricing pages, tested KeePassXC and the Bitwarden command line in throwaway containers on our own server, and found three things most comparisons never mention:
1. A KeePassXC database freshly created from the command line unlocked in 44 milliseconds. Convenient, but just as fast for an attacker who steals the file. A single option raised the cost per attempt to 3.05 seconds, roughly 70 times slower to brute-force.
2. Exports are plaintext by default with both open-source candidates. KeePassXC wrote our CSV file with every password readable by every user on the system (
-rw-r--r--). The Bitwarden CLI also exports to unencrypted CSV unless told otherwise.3. Prices are moving fast. Bitwarden Premium now costs $19.80 a year instead of the old $10, 1Password advertises an introductory price that jumps from $2.99 to $3.99 a month after twelve months, and Proton Pass also renews higher than its first-year price.

Why use a password manager at all?
Because no human can remember 150 different, long, random passwords. Yet that is exactly what you need so that a data breach at some online shop does not automatically unlock your email account too. Attackers systematically try stolen credentials on other services. This is called credential stuffing, and it only works because people reuse passwords.
A password manager solves this by asking you for exactly one password: the master password. It generates and remembers everything else. On top of that you get autofill in the browser, warnings about weak or leaked passwords and, increasingly, management of passkeys, the passwordless login standard.
How big the difference is shows up in keepassxc-cli estimate, which estimates password strength. We fed it two candidates:
| Password | Length | Estimated entropy |
|---|---|---|
Sommer2026! (typical human password) | 11 characters | 23.6 bits |
| six random words (Diceware, generated by KeePassXC) | 43 characters | 127.8 bits |
Every bit doubles the attacker’s workload. A gap of 104 bits means the word-based password is not slightly better, it is in a completely different league. And it is still memorable because it consists of real words. That is the kind of password you should use as your master password, whichever manager you choose.
If you want to dig deeper into attacks: in our overview of IT security vulnerabilities we explain why stolen credentials are among the most common ways in.
The four candidates at a glance
Before going into detail, here are the most important differences. Prices are public list prices in US dollars with annual billing, read on 17 Nov 2026. They may differ in euros or via app stores.
| Bitwarden | KeePassXC | 1Password | Proton Pass | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | cloud or self-hosted | local file | cloud | cloud |
| Free version | yes, unlimited passwords and devices | completely free | no (trial only) | yes, unlimited logins and devices |
| Paid, individual | $19.80/year ($1.65/month) | – | $3.99/month, $2.99 in year 1 | $1.99/month in year 1, then $35.88/year |
| Family | $47.88/year, up to 6 people | – | $5.99/month, 5 people | $33.48 in year 1, then $59.88/year, 6 people |
| Open source | yes (clients mostly GPL-3.0) | yes (GPL) | no | yes (clients GPL-3.0) |
| Self-hosting | yes (official or Vaultwarden) | not needed | no | no |
| Official mobile app | yes | no, third-party apps only | yes | yes |
| Current version (17 Nov 2026) | desktop 2026.10.4, CLI 2026.10.1 | 2.8.0, released 21 Oct 2026 | – | – |
The most important row is the first one. It decides more than any feature: where does your vault live? With a vendor in the cloud, on your own server, or as a file on your computer. Everything else follows from that.
Comparison by Cybernews (October 2026). Note: the channel earns from affiliate links in its video description. We don’t.
How password managers protect your data
All four candidates share the same basic principle: encryption happens on your device. Your master password never leaves your computer. A key is derived from it locally, and only the fully encrypted vault travels to the cloud or the disk. Vendors call this zero knowledge: the provider holds your data but cannot read it.
That sounds like a promise you have to take on faith. It only partly is. With Bitwarden, KeePassXC and Proton Pass the app source code is public, so experts can verify that only encrypted data leaves the device. With 1Password you rely on third-party audits commissioned by the company. That is not automatically worse, but it is a different kind of trust.

The crucial building block: key derivation
The real protection against stolen vaults is the key derivation function (KDF). It deliberately makes every single check of a master password expensive. An attacker who has grabbed your encrypted vault must run this expensive computation for each guess.
That this is not theoretical was shown by LastPass: at the end of 2022, encrypted customer vaults were stolen. How dangerous that was for an individual depended almost entirely on two things: the strength of the master password, and the number of derivation iterations, which was set very low on some older accounts.
Here is how the four candidates handle it:
- Bitwarden uses PBKDF2 with 600,000 iterations by default. In the account settings you can switch to Argon2id, which also requires a lot of memory and therefore slows down GPU attacks.
- KeePassXC stores the setting in the database file itself. You do not set iterations but a target time: how long should unlocking take? Our measurement follows below.
- 1Password combines your master password with a Secret Key, a random 34-character key that only lives on your devices. A stolen vault is practically uncrackable even with a weak master password, because the attacker lacks the Secret Key. It is the strongest answer to the LastPass scenario, but it costs convenience: without the Secret Key you cannot sign in on a new device either.
- Proton Pass uses the encryption of your Proton account. Your vault is tied to the Proton login, including its two-factor authentication.
Our test: how fast can a KeePassXC file be cracked?
With KeePassXC, the file is everything. Anyone who gets hold of it, for example via a stolen laptop or a wrongly shared cloud folder, can guess offline for as long as they like. So we wanted to know how well a fresh database is protected out of the box.
Setup: Alpine Linux in a throwaway container, KeePassXC CLI 2.7.12, AMD EPYC server. Important: the new version 2.8.0 had not reached the package repositories on test day. Alpine edge shipped 2.7.12, Debian 13 only 2.7.10. That is normal for KeePassXC, as Linux distributions often lag weeks or months behind. If you want the latest version, use the official AppImage or Flatpak.
We created three databases with the same master password and opened each three times:
| Created with | Key derivation according to db-info | Unlock (average) |
|---|---|---|
keepassxc-cli db-create -p (no option) | AES-KDF, 1,000,000 rounds | 44 ms |
… -t 1000 (target 1 second) | AES-KDF, 53,571,428 rounds | 1,028 ms |
… -t 3000 (target 3 seconds) | AES-KDF, 160,714,272 rounds | 3,057 ms |
A wrong password took exactly as long as the right one (39 ms, 1,026 ms and 3,045 ms). That is how it should be: every guess costs the attacker the full time.
What does that mean in practice? At 44 ms a single CPU core manages about 23 guesses per second; at 3 seconds only one every three seconds. An attacker with many cores or GPUs gets further, of course, but the ratio holds: the -t 3000 option makes each guess about 70 times more expensive. It costs you three seconds when unlocking, and with quick unlock via fingerprint or system password (new in 2.8.0 on Linux via Polkit) you hardly notice in daily use.
Two caveats. First, the desktop app creates new databases with its own defaults and also offers Argon2, which additionally demands a lot of memory and protects better against GPUs than AES-KDF. Our test mainly shows what happens when you create a database from a script without paying attention. Second, a strong master password beats any iteration count. A six-word Diceware password cannot be guessed in this universe even at 44 ms per attempt. The iteration count is the seatbelt for everyone whose master password is weaker than they think.
Our recommendation: in KeePassXC, check Database → Database Settings → Security to see which derivation is configured, and set the decryption time to at least one second. On the command line, pass -t 1000 or more when creating the database.

What else is in the file
Our empty test database was 1,806 bytes; with 200 entries it grew to 15,230 bytes. We searched the file for the entry titles: not a single hit, usernames and URLs are encrypted too. Only the file header is readable, which programs use to recognise a KeePass database. A key file as a second factor (--set-key-file) was 128 bytes and created readable only by its owner (-r--------). That is a good addition when the database lives in a cloud folder: without the key file, which stays on your devices, the password alone is useless to whoever has the cloud copy.
One small detail: with a wrong password, the command line says “If this reoccurs, then your database file may be corrupt.” That sounds like a broken file but usually just means a typo. No need to panic, and no reason to restore your backup straight away.
The export trap: plaintext for everyone
Every password manager can export its vault. You need that to switch and to keep your own backup. This is exactly where the biggest real-world mistake happens, and it happens before the program, not in it.
KeePassXC: in our test, keepassxc-cli export -f csv wrote a CSV file with every entry in plaintext: group, title, username, password, URL, notes, TOTP. The file got permissions -rw-r--r--, readable by any user on the system. That is down to the system’s default umask, not KeePassXC itself. But the program does not warn you either.
Bitwarden: the CLI in version 2026.10.1 (90 MB installed) supports the formats csv, json, encrypted_json and zip. The default is csv, i.e. plaintext as well. With --format encrypted_json --password … you get an export protected by its own password that can still be imported into another account. That is the format to use for backups.
Our rules for exports:
- Never export into a synced folder (Dropbox, OneDrive, Nextcloud, a Downloads folder with cloud sync).
- Use an encrypted export whenever possible. With KeePassXC, the
.kdbxfile itself is already the best backup. - Delete plaintext exports immediately after importing and empty the trash.
- If you want an offline backup, it belongs encrypted on a USB stick in a drawer. How to build that properly is covered in our 3-2-1 backup strategy.
Bitwarden: the all-rounder with the best free plan
Bitwarden is our default recommendation. The reason is simple: the free plan has no limits on passwords or devices. You get apps for Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, Linux, every major browser and the command line, plus passkey management, a generator, email alias integration, encrypted export and Bitwarden Send for sharing text securely. Sharing with one other person is also free.
Premium at $19.80 a year mainly adds three things: a built-in TOTP generator for two-factor codes, 5 GB of encrypted storage for attachments (such as a scan of your passport) and emergency access, which lets a trusted person request access in an emergency. On top come security reports on weak, reused and leaked passwords and support for hardware keys like YubiKey. Families costs $47.88 a year for up to six people.
The price increase from $10 to $19.80 has annoyed some users. Honestly, though, Bitwarden Premium is still the cheapest paid plan of the four once you compare renewal prices rather than first-year promotions.
Its big strength: self-hosting. Bitwarden is the only one of the four cloud candidates you can move entirely to your own server, either with the official server or with the lean reimplementation Vaultwarden. We run this ourselves and documented our experience in our Vaultwarden setup guide, including the four traps you are likely to hit, such as registration being open by default. In our measurement, Vaultwarden used just 7.9 MB of RAM when idle.
Weaknesses: the interface is functional but not pretty. Autofill inside mobile apps is sometimes clunkier than with 1Password. And if you self-host, updates, backups and hardening are your job.
Who is it for? Almost everyone. Especially people who do not want to pay, families, and anyone who values the option to self-host.
KeePassXC: full control, no cloud at all
KeePassXC is not a service but a program. Your passwords live in a single encrypted file in the open KDBX format. There is no account, no vendor, no server and no cost. If the project shut down tomorrow, you could still open your file with a dozen other KeePass-compatible programs. No other candidate offers that independence.
Version 2.8.0 from 21 October 2026 is a big update: migration to Qt 6, configurable keyboard shortcuts, remote database synchronisation via third-party tools, Auto-Type on Wayland, quick unlock on Linux via Polkit and native Windows on ARM builds. It also fixes several security issues, including a bug when importing crafted KDB files and memory errors in communication with the browser extension. Reason enough to update.
KeePassXC can do more than many people think: TOTP codes, passkeys, a browser extension, an SSH agent (which in 2.8.0 can also generate keys, matching our guide on how to generate an SSH key), leaked-password checks against the Have I Been Pwned database and hardware keys via YubiKey challenge-response.
Its big weakness: sync and mobile. KeePassXC itself only exists for Windows, macOS and Linux. On your phone you need apps from other developers, such as KeePassDX for Android or KeePassium and Strongbox for iOS. To keep the file identical everywhere, you put it in a sync folder (Nextcloud, Syncthing, a cloud of your choice). That works well until you change something on two devices at the same time. Then you get conflicts you have to merge yourself. That is the price of freedom.

Who is it for? People who do not want to trust any cloud, admins and developers, and anyone who mostly needs their passwords on a computer. Less suited to families who simply want to share logins.
1Password: the smoothest experience, but only for money
1Password is the opposite of KeePassXC: closed source, only in the vendor’s cloud, but very polished. The apps look good, autofill is reliable, and features like Watchtower (security reports), Travel Mode (hides selected vaults when crossing borders) and good family management are well thought out. Wirecutter, the New York Times’ product review team, recommends 1Password especially for beginners because its help pages and explanations are particularly good.
On security, the Secret Key is its strongest argument. Because it enters the encryption alongside the master password and never sits on 1Password’s servers, a stolen vault would be practically worthless to attackers. That is a real advantage over every other cloud solution.
The catch is the price. There is no free plan, only a trial. According to the pricing page, Individual costs $3.99 a month billed annually, $2.99 for new customers in the first year. Families costs $5.99 a month for five people, $4.49 in the first year. The discounts only apply when you subscribe directly on the website, not via app stores. Compared with Bitwarden Premium you pay more than double after year one.
Who is it for? Anyone willing to pay to think about it as little as possible. Families with little tech experience. And teams already looking for a business product.
Proton Pass: the privacy pick with email aliases
Proton Pass comes from the Swiss company behind Proton Mail and Proton VPN. The apps are open source (GPL-3.0) and run on Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, Linux and all major browsers. The free plan is surprisingly generous: unlimited logins, notes and credit cards, unlimited devices, passkeys and 10 email aliases. Vaults are limited: 2 on the free plan, 50 on paid plans.
Its standout feature is hide-my-email aliases. When you create a new account, Proton Pass can generate a random email address on the spot that forwards to your real inbox. If the shop gets hacked or sells your address, you simply switch the alias off. Pass Plus gives you unlimited aliases, custom domains for aliases, a built-in 2FA code generator, vault sharing and dark web monitoring.
Look closely at the pricing. Pass Plus costs $4.99 monthly. Billed annually, you pay $23.88 for the first year ($1.99 a month), then it renews at $35.88 a year. Pass Family for six people costs $33.48 in the first year, then $59.88. If you book Proton Unlimited anyway ($77.88 in year one, then $119.88), you get Pass Plus together with Mail, Drive and VPN.
Who is it for? Anyone already in the Proton ecosystem or who wants to use email aliases heavily, and people who value a European provider with open apps. Proton Pass cannot be self-hosted.
1Password vs Bitwarden comparison by VPNpro (October 2026). Again, the video description contains the channel’s affiliate links.
Password manager comparison: what does it really cost over three years?
Because the introductory discounts vary so much, we calculated the cost over three years using list prices from 17 Nov 2026 with annual billing:
| Scenario | Bitwarden | KeePassXC | 1Password | Proton Pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Individual, free version | $0 | $0 | not possible | $0 |
| Individual, paid, 3 years | $59.40 | $0 | $131.64 (35.88 + 2 × 47.88) | $95.64 (23.88 + 2 × 35.88) |
| Family, 3 years | $143.64 (6 people) | $0 | $197.64 (53.88 + 2 × 71.88, 5 people) | $153.24 (33.48 + 2 × 59.88, 6 people) |
| Self-hosted (Vaultwarden) | server cost, often already there | – | – | – |
For Bitwarden, keep in mind that most people do not need Premium at all. You can get a TOTP generator in a separate authenticator app, and many consider that more secure because password and second factor then do not sit in the same vault.
Do I even need a separate password manager?
Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge have built-in password managers, and they have improved a lot. Google and Apple sync them encrypted, and Apple even ships a standalone Passwords app. For someone living in a single ecosystem that is a reasonable start and certainly better than reusing one password everywhere.
A dedicated password manager is still worth it if any of these apply:
- You use several ecosystems, for example an Android phone and a Mac, or Firefox and Chrome.
- You want to share passwords with family or a partner without everyone using the same Google or Apple account.
- You do not want the protection of your passwords to hinge on your Google or Apple account.
- You also want to manage secure notes, ID scans, SSH keys or recovery codes.
If you use several browsers, our comparison of open-source web browsers shows which ones get by without a big corporation behind them. The browser’s password storage is usually the first thing people replace with a dedicated manager.
Passkeys: do they make password managers obsolete?
No, quite the opposite. Passkeys replace a website password with a key pair: the private key stays on your device, the website only knows the public key. Phishing fails because the passkey only works on the genuine domain.
But those keys have to live somewhere and sync between your devices. All four candidates can now do this, Bitwarden and Proton Pass even on their free plans, KeePassXC locally in the file. The advantage over Apple or Google: your passkeys are not locked into one ecosystem. And because many sites will offer both for a long time, you need a place for passwords and passkeys together anyway.
Switching: how to move from one manager to another
Migrating is easy with all four candidates because they all import common formats. Bitwarden imports under Tools → Import data from 1Password, KeePass, LastPass, Proton Pass, Chrome, Firefox and many more. KeePassXC imports CSV, 1Password exports and, since 2.8.0, extended entry types from Proton Pass such as Wi-Fi credentials and SSH keys. Proton Pass and 1Password have their own import wizards.
The safe process:
- Update the old manager and sync it one last time.
- Create the export, ideally straight into a local folder that is not synced.
- Import into the new manager and spot-check: a login with special characters in the password, an entry with TOTP, a secure note, an attachment.
- Delete the export file and empty the trash.
- Keep the old manager for a few weeks but turn off its autofill so no new passwords end up there.
Attachments and passkeys are often lost in exports. In many cases you have to move them by hand, or re-register passkeys on the websites.
What we did not test
To keep this comparison honest, here are its limits. We tried KeePassXC and the Bitwarden CLI ourselves in throwaway containers and have been running Vaultwarden for weeks. We did not create new 1Password and Proton Pass accounts for this article; there we rely on the official pricing and feature pages as of 17 Nov 2026 and on published tests. We did not perform security audits and did not test browser extensions for phishing detection. Our KDF measurement ran on a server CPU; on a laptop or phone the times will differ, but the ratio between settings stays the same.
FAQ: common questions about this password manager comparison
Which password manager is the best?
There is no single winner. For most people Bitwarden is the best balance of price, security and platforms, because its free version has no limits on passwords or devices. KeePassXC is best if you want no cloud at all. 1Password has the best user experience but costs money. Proton Pass is ideal for Proton users and anyone who wants email aliases.
Which password manager is free and still good?
Bitwarden Free, Proton Pass Free and KeePassXC. Bitwarden and Proton Pass offer unlimited passwords on unlimited devices for free. KeePassXC is entirely free, with no paid tier. 1Password has no free plan.
Is Bitwarden safe?
Yes. Encryption happens on your device, by default with PBKDF2 at 600,000 iterations, optionally with Argon2id. The apps are open source and regularly audited by third parties. The biggest risk is a weak master password. Use four to six random words and enable two-step login.
KeePassXC or Bitwarden: which is better?
It depends on where your vault should live. KeePassXC stores a file that you sync yourself: maximum control but more manual work, especially on mobile. Bitwarden syncs automatically via the cloud or your own server. If you are torn between the two, Bitwarden with a self-hosted Vaultwarden combines control with convenience.
What happens if my password manager gets hacked?
With a cloud provider, attackers at worst steal your encrypted vault. Whether they can open it depends on your master password and the key derivation. With a long, random master password a stolen vault is practically worthless. 1Password adds the Secret Key on top. Still, after such an incident, change your most important passwords, starting with email and banking.
Is the password manager built into my browser enough?
For a start, yes, and it is far better than reused passwords. A dedicated manager pays off once you use several browsers or operating systems, want to share passwords, or do not want everything to depend on your Google or Apple account.
What happens if I forget my master password?
With all four candidates your vault is usually lost, which is the whole point of zero knowledge. The vendor cannot reset your password. Bitwarden offers emergency access (Premium) via a trusted person, 1Password has its printable Emergency Kit, and Proton has its own account recovery methods. Write your master password on paper and keep it somewhere safe.
Should I store two-factor codes in my password manager?
It is a trade-off. Keeping them in the same vault is more convenient and still helps against phishing. If you want maximum security, separate them and use a dedicated authenticator app or a hardware key for TOTP codes. Either way, protect the password manager itself with a second factor.
Can I self-host a password manager?
Of the four candidates, only Bitwarden, either with the official server or with Vaultwarden. KeePassXC needs no server because it is a file. 1Password and Proton Pass run only on the vendor’s infrastructure. Our Vaultwarden guide shows how self-hosting works step by step and which traps to avoid.
How safe is a KeePassXC file in the cloud?
As safe as your master password and the configured key derivation. Check under Database Settings → Security that unlocking takes at least one second, or use Argon2. A key file that stays on your devices and never goes to the cloud adds another layer.
Is there KeePassXC for mobile?
Not from the KeePassXC team itself. Proven options are KeePassDX on Android and KeePassium and Strongbox on iOS. They open the same KDBX file; sync runs through a cloud folder or Syncthing.
Is 1Password worth the price?
If convenience matters to you and you are happy to pay, yes. The Secret Key is a genuine security advantage. But budget for the renewal price of $3.99 a month, not the introductory discount. By our calculation, 1Password Individual costs more than twice as much as Bitwarden Premium over three years.

Conclusion: our password manager comparison in one sentence per candidate
- Bitwarden: the best default for almost everyone, with the strongest free plan and the option to move everything to your own server.
- KeePassXC: the right choice if you trust no cloud and can live with a bit of manual work for syncing. Turn up the decryption time.
- 1Password: the most convenient option with the cleverest protection against stolen vaults, but no free plan and the most expensive after year one.
- Proton Pass: the European privacy pick with a generous free tier and the best email aliases.
Far more important than which program you choose are three things that apply to all of them: a long, random master password made of several words, two-factor authentication for the password manager itself, and never leaving plaintext exports lying around. Get those right and you are far safer with any of the four than with the one password you use everywhere.